Club Honours

Welsh Football Magazine Programme Awards
Achievement Award Presented by Penycae Community Council in recognition of the clubs achievements between 1982 – 1994.
F.A. Of Wales Bronze Accredited Club
F.A. Of Wales Silver Accredited Club

Penycae FC 1st Team Honours

Welsh National League (Wrexham area)
League Honours

Division 4 Runners Up 1982/83
Division 3 Champions 1983/84
Division 1 Runners Up 1984/85
Premier Division Champions 1993/94
Premier Division Runners Up 2000/01, 2001/2002, 2002/03, 2003/04

Cup Honours

North East Wales Football Association Horace Wynne Cup Winners 1982/83, 1983/84, 1984/85
North East Wales Football Association Challenge Cup Semi Finalists 1994/85, 1999/2000, 2000/01
North East Wales Football Association Challenge Cup Finalists 1997/98
Division 4 Cup Finalists 1982/83
Division 3 Cup Winners 1983/84
Division 1 Cup Semi Finalists 1984/85
Premier Division Cup Semi Finalists 1991/92, 2001/01, 2006/07,2007/08,
Dave Bennett Premier Division Cup Winners 1993/94
Cymru Alliance Cup Runners up 1996/97
FAW Welsh Trophy Winners 2003/04

Penycae FC Reserve Team Honours

Welsh National League (Wrexham area)
League Honours

Division 4 Runners Up 1983/84
Division 2 Champions 1985/86

Cup Honours

Division 2 Cup Finalists 1985/86
Division 1 Cup Semi Finalists 2007/08
Horace Wynne Trophy Semi Finalists 2007/08